Sydney Sweeney is not the problem. We are.

The Sydney Sweeney effect (Sophia Kaur Nagra / The Puma Prensa)

By Rheya Bushan and Sophia Nagra

Sydney Sweeney.

It’s a name I know all of us are getting tired of hearing. From advertising American Eagle to Novig, companies that aren’t inherently or necessarily evil, Sweeney has sparked immense controversy, grabbing the attention of women from around the world to protect the authority and respect we fought so hard for generations to inherit. 

In her most recent advertisement for Novig, a sports betting company, Sweeney has become the face of yet another controversy. The campaign, titled “Just Sports,” features Sweeney posing nearly nude with various sporting equipment, including footballs, basketballs, and hockey gear, while promoting the company’s platform.

The advertisement has drawn criticism from female athletes around the world, who argue that its sexualized portrayal of women undermines the years of dedication, discipline, and physical strength required to compete in professional sports.

Olympic gold medalist Ariarne Titmus called the advertisement “a kick in the face” to women who have dedicated their lives to their athletic careers, questioning why women’s bodies continue to be monetized and sexualized in the name of sports, with many other female athletes such as Amy Hunt and Gracie Kramer chiming in.

However, Sweeney’s involvement in the campaign extends beyond simply being its spokesperson. She is an equity holder and strategic partner in Novig, and reportedly helped shape the advertisement’s creative direction. This complicates the conversation surrounding her responsibility, particularly when considering that the campaign was not simply a corporate decision made without her involvement.

And yet, while the criticism surrounding the advertisement is certainly worth examining, I find myself asking a familiar question: Why does our outrage so often become centered on the woman in front of the camera, rather than the larger industries that continue to profit from the objectification of women?

For American Eagle, the issue was found on matters of race, with public discourse mentioning the parallels between her script:

Genes are passed down from parent to offspring, often determining traits like hair color, personality, and even eye color. My genes are blue.

Sydney Sweeney has great genes.

And eugenics.

Given that the homophone of “jeans” and “genes” are equating great genes to blue eyes– many have found it disturbing that the campaign seems to flirt with an ideology that has historically been used to justify racial superiority.

While there is no definitive evidence that Sweeney intended to promote eugenics, the criticism is worth examining. After all, an advertisement does not exist in a vacuum. The language, imagery, and historical associations behind it matter, regardless of what its creators claim to have intended.

But I think there is another conversation we are failing to have.

We are just as much a part of the problem as she is.

We are putting the blame and focus on yet another woman in order to “defend women,” all while ignoring the larger issue: the patriarchal views and white supremacy that continue to dictate our society. We have become so accustomed to criticizing women for how they present themselves, what they wear, what they say, and what they represent that we sometimes fail to recognize when we are participating in the very behavior we claim to oppose.

Think about how so many young girls have had a phase in their lives where they pretended to hate the color pink. Not necessarily because they disliked the color itself, but because of what wearing it represented. Pink was feminine, and feminine was often synonymous with weak, incapable, unintelligent, or unoriginal.

We distanced ourselves from anything considered traditionally girly because we wanted to be taken seriously. We wanted to prove that we were different from the stereotypes attached to women.

On March 16 of 2026, ABC cancelled Secret Lives of Mormon Wives television and social media star Taylor Frankie Paul’s season of the bachelorette because of a video that leaked earlier. The video, published by TMZ, depicted Paul kicking, pushing, grabbing the hair of, and throwing a chair at her boyfriend, Dakota Mortenson, all while in front of her daughter, who got injured by the metal chair she threw. While the network knew of her arrest in 2023 and legal charges including aggravated assault, child abuse, and domestic violence in the presence of a child– they banked on her popularity with SLOMW  to drive views and ratings. While there is absolutely no doubt that Paul’s actions were inexcusable and ABC did the right thing by cancelling her season– it still brings into question: Why did ABC allow her on the show in the first place? Why is it that men that have done far worse and still face less, if any, repercussions?

Take the Cornell 7, who are still yet to face any legal consequences for gang raping a girl for 7 hours while advertising her body as “free p*ssy” to their fraternity. 

Take Donald Trump, convicted of 34 felony counts and found liable for sexual abuse and defamation, cited in the Epstein files over 380,000 times– far more than the 980 of even Jesus in the Bible– who is still one of the most powerful men on the planet, and sitting president of the United States.

It is a familiar pattern. A woman wears something revealing, and suddenly her clothing becomes a public discussion. A woman participates in athletics, and her body becomes something to comment on rather than something that deserves respect for its ability and strength. A woman becomes successful, attractive or influential, and her appearance becomes a reason to scrutinize her rather than recognize her accomplishments.

At what point do we stop asking women to change how they dress, behave, advertise, or exist, and start asking why men feel so entitled to evaluate them in the first place?

And that brings us back to Sydney Sweeney.

The American Eagle campaign was not created by Sweeney alone. It was a commercial campaign developed and promoted by a corporation, with creative and marketing leadership behind it. American Eagle’s own president and executive creative director, Jennifer Foyle, publicly discussed the campaign.

The responsibility for its messaging, therefore, cannot reasonably rest on the shoulders of the woman standing in front of the camera alone.

We can criticize Sweeney’s participation. We can question the campaign’s messaging. We can demand that companies understand the historical implication of the imagery they put into the world. But if we stop at criticizing the women whose face we recognize, we allow the people making the decisions to remain comfortably out of sight.

We are just as much the problem as her. By saying that she is “singlehandedly setting women back generations,” while holding some partial truths, we are giving in to the patriarchy, continuing it to let it dictate our society and the way we treat women. Putting the blame and focus of objectification on yet another woman in order to defend women, all while ignoring the real issue– why are we more concerned about “them not taking us seriously anymore because of Sydney Sweeney’s ad campaigns” and not the them who never took us seriously. The them who never thought twice before objectifying, harassing, abusing, discriminating against us. 

And, yes Sydney Sweeney’s actions and advertisements certainly haven’t been helpful. But, by tearing her down more than any man has, we stoop to their level– bringing each other down while the patriarchy still stands, only growing in strength and influence, even amidst a new “woke” and “highly sensitive” generation.

So no, Sydney Sweeney is not the problem. We are.

Next
Next

The hidden costs of sports betting: a new pandemic hitting America